James Hansen says belief in renewable energy same as believing in the Easter Bunny or Tooth Fairy

Andrew Revkin at the New York Times, comments on a James Hansen video that makes the case for nuclear energy (sorry James — that won’t work either).

James Hansen: Believing in renewable energy is like believing in the Easter Bunny and the Tooth Fairy

In a 2011 essay, “Baby Lauren and the Kool-Aid“, Hansen wrote: “Can renewable energies provide all of society’s energy needs in the foreseeable future? It is conceivable in a few places, such as New Zealand and Norway. But suggesting that renewables will let us phase rapidly off fossil fuels in the United States, China, India, or the world as a whole is almost the equivalent of believing in the Easter Bunny and Tooth Fairy.

Hansen: Whatever carbon you don’t use, others will

“It’s useful to show that you can have a lifestyle which produce less carbon, but it doesn’t solve the problem. Because if that’s all that happens, even if you convince a thousand people or a million people or a billion people to reduce their emissions what it does is reduce the demand for the fuel, lowers its price and somebody else will burn it.”

Hansen on renewable energy

“I think it’s unfortunate that so many environmentalists are just assuming that these renewable energies will be able to satisfy all of our requirements. Renewables are only providing between 1 and 2 percent — the soft renewables. Hydropower provides a significant amount of electricity but that’s limited. The hope that the wind and the sun and geothermal can provide all of our energy is a nice idea but I find it unlikely that that’s possible.

The environmental community is basically asking governments to try to reduce their emissions and asking them to subsidize clean energies. Well, that simply doesn’t work because we don’t get enough energy from the renewables to make a difference. And that then forces any government to approve expanded oil drilling, hydro-fracking to get more gas, mountaintop removal to get coal. We’re not going to turn the lights out. No government, no president or governor is going to turn out the lights. There has to be energy. If renewables aren’t providing it, it’s been fossil fuels.”

Andrew Revkin. July 23, 2013.  Jim Hansen Presses the Climate Case for Nuclear Energy. New York Times.

This entry was posted in Alternative Energy, James Hansen. Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.