Black starting the grid after a power outage

Toronto during the 2003 Northeast blackout, which required black-starting of generating stations. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_start

Black starts

Large blackouts can be quite devastating and it isn’t easy to restart the electric grid again.

This is typically done by designated black start units of natural gas, coal, hydro, or nuclear power plants that can restart themselves using their own power with no help from the rest of the electrical grid.  Not all power plants can restart themselves.

After a brief introduction to black starts, I have a recent example of one in Venezuela to give you an idea of how hard restarting a grid can be.

Clearly a renewable grid running mainly on wind and solar will crash a lot, and without hydropower or fossil fuels to restart the grid (which are finite and won’t be available at some point), the idea we can just do stuff when the grid is up and wait it out for when the grid is down isn’t going to work.  This is a huge problem for a 100% renewable system that may not be solvable.  Microgrids don’t solve anything, manufacturing and industry require mind-boggling amounts to electricity to stay in business.

Alice Friedemann   www.energyskeptic.com  author of “When Trucks Stop Running: Energy and the Future of Transportation”, 2015, Springer and “Crunch! Whole Grain Artisan Chips and Crackers”. Podcasts: Practical Prepping, KunstlerCast 253, KunstlerCast278, Peak Prosperity , XX2 report

***

In regions lucky enough to have hydropower (just 10 states have 80% of the hydropower in the U.S.) this is usually the designated black start source since a hydroelectric station needs very little initial power to start, and can put a large block of power on line very quickly to allow start-up of fossil-fuel or nuclear stations.

Wind turbines are not suitable for black start because wind may not be available when needed (Fox 2007) and likewise solar power plants suffer from the same problem.

The impact of a blackout exponentially increases with the duration of the blackout, and the duration of restoration decreases exponentially with the availability of initial sources of power. For several time-critical loads, quick restoration (minutes rather than hours or even days) is crucial. Blackstart generators, which can be started without any connection to the grid, are a key element in restoring service after a widespread outage. These initial sources of power include pump-storage hydropower, which can take 5-10 minutes to start, to certain types of combustion turbines, which take on the order of hours.

For a limited outage, restoration can be rapid, which will then allow sufficient time for repair to bring the system to full operability, although there may be a challenge for subsurface cables in metropolitan areas. On the other hand, in widespread outages, restoration itself may be a significant barrier, as was the case in the 1965 and 2003 Northeast blackouts. Natural disasters, however, can also lead to significant issues of repair—after Hurricanes Rita and Katrina, full repair of the electric power system took several years (NAS)

Restoring a system from a blackout required a very careful choreography of re-energizing transmission lines from generators that were still online inside the blacked-out area, from systems from outside the blacked-out area, restoring station power to off-line generating units so they could be restarted, synchronizing the generators to the interconnection, and then constantly balancing generation and demand as additional generating units and additional customer demands are restored to service.

Many may not realize it takes days to bring nuclear and coal fired power plants back on-line, so restoring power was done with gas-fired plants normally used for peak periods to cover baseload needs normally coal and nuclear-powered. The diversity of our energy systems proved invaluable (CR).

Restarting the grid after the 2003 power outage was especially difficult.

The blackout shutdown over 100 power plants, including 22 nuclear reactors, cutoff power for 50 million people in 8 states and Canada, including much of the Northeast corridor and the core of the American financial network, and showed just how vulnerable our tightly knit network of generators, transmission lines, and other critical infrastructure is.

The dependence of major infrastructural systems on the continued supply of electrical energy, and of oil and gas, is well recognized. Telecommunications, information technology, and the Internet, as well as food and water supplies, homes and worksites, are dependent on electricity; numerous commercial and transportation facilities are also dependent on natural gas and refined oil products.

Newman, L. H. 2018. Why it’s so hard to restart Venezuela’s power grid. Wired.com

Venezuela’s massive nationwide power outages, which began on Thursday, have so far resulted in at least 20 deaths, looting, and loss of access to food, water, fuel, and cash for many of the country’s 31 million residents. Late Monday, the United States said its diplomats would leave the US embassy in Caracas, citing deteriorating conditions. As the societal impacts intensify and Venezuela’s internal power struggle continues, the country is clearly struggling to restart its grid and meaningfully restore power—a problem exacerbated by its aging infrastructure.

Reenergizing a dead grid, a process known as a black start, is challenging under any circumstances.

Government statements and reports indicate that the blackout stems from a problem at the enormous Guri dam hydropower plant in eastern Venezuela, which generates 80 percent of the country’s electricity. And the already arduous process of restoring power seems hobbled by years of system neglect. It’s also unclear whether Venezuela has the specialists, workforce, and spare equipment available on the ground to triage the situation quickly.

“The challenge with black start is always just knowing specifically what happened,” says Nathan Wallace, director of cyber operations and a staff engineer at secure grid companies Cybirical and Ampirical Solutions. “It sounds like there may be lack of maintenance and some mismanagement. And typically if a system hasn’t been maintained, that means they really don’t have the visualization needed to understand the state of the system in real time. If the procedure for black start is not accurately representing the state of the system, there can be problems.”

A black start generally involves seeding power from an independent source—like small diesel generators or natural gas turbines—to restart power plants in an otherwise dead transmission network. This process is often called bootstrapping. Hydroelectric plants in particular can be designed to essentially black-start themselves. In these plants, water—often from a dam, as in the case of Guri—flows through a turbine, which spins it, powering an electric generator. Since it takes relatively little independent energy to open the water intake gates and potentially generate a lot of power very quickly, hydroelectric plants can work well for black start. It is unclear whether Venezuela’s Guri plant is designed with this scenario in mind.

What makes any black-start process especially complicated is the need to load balance a system, so that as power surges through, the supply from the generator matches the demand. Otherwise the generation plant will run too fast or be exhausted, causing the system to fail again.

It’s a large stepwise process to build up load, build up generation, build up more load, build up more generation until they’ve got enough reliability to go to the next element of the system. If a utility has issues with maintenance, or has a history of operational issues, or they don’t have a plan, or that plan is outdated, or if they don’t have a really good understanding of the limitations of the grid system, everything the utility is attempting to do becomes far more difficult.

Venezuela’s grid is based on a classic model of bulk power generation. From a centralized plant—in this case, Guri—substations transform electricity from low to high voltage so it can be transmitted all over the country and then converted back down to lower voltage for local distribution. This is fairly typical in small countries, though some prioritize adding diverse generation or connecting with neighboring grids to increase redundancy. Black-start researchers and practitioners say, though, that any model has pros and cons. While distributed systems don’t have a single point of generation failure, they can be more difficult to black start if they do go down, since more generation sites need to be bootstrapped and there are more loads to balance.

Regardless of the setup, the crucial component of all black starts is understanding what caused the outage, having the ability to fix it, and working with a system that can handle the power surges and fluctuations involved in bringing power back online. Without all of these elements in place, says Tim Yardley, a senior researcher at the University of Illinois focused on industrial control crisis simulations, black starts can be prohibitively difficult to execute.

“Reenergizing a grid in some ways is more of a shock to the system than it operating in its norm,” Yardley says. “If infrastructure is aging, and there’s a lack of maintenance and repairs, as you try to turn it back on and try to balance the loads you may have stuff that’s not going to come back up, infrastructure that’s been physically damaged or that was in such a bad state of repair that reenergizing it causes other problems.”

Crews attempting to deal with black-starting a frail and brittle grid also face major safety considerations, like explosions. “You have a maintenance issue and a manpower issue, because it’s extremely dangerous to reenergize a system if you have gear that hasn’t been maintained well,” Yardley notes.

Venezuela has faced years of power instability since about 2009, including two major blackouts in 2013 and a power and water crisis in 2016. At times the blackouts were caused in part by weather conditions like El Niño, but overall they have established a pattern of poor planning, mismanagement, and lack of investment on the part of the government. President Maduro has repeatedly overseen rationing efforts resulting in erratic power and has even set official national clocks back to put the country’s morning commute in daylight.

References

CR. September 4 & 23, 2003. Implications of power blackouts for the nation’s cybersecurity and critical infrastructure protection. Congressional Record, House of Representatives. Serial No. 108–23. Christopher Cox, California, Chairman select committee on homeland security

Fox, Brendan et al; Wind Power Integration – Connection and System Operational Aspects, Institution of Engineering and Technology, 2007 page 245

NAS. 2012. Terrorism and the Electric Power Delivery System. National Academy of Science

NAS. 2013. The Resilience of the Electric Power Delivery System in Response to Terrorism and Natural Disasters. National Academy of Science

Please follow and like us:
error
This entry was posted in Grid instability and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Black starting the grid after a power outage

  1. Dan Taylor says:

    I know for a fact that Ontario Hydro’s nuclear facilities on Lake Ontario were well on their way to a melt down as there was no power to the cooling pumps.
    It still isn’t a good situation in the nuclear industry and clearly poses an existential threat to mankind.
    Most of the billions that are currently be wasted on security agencies would much better be spent on hardening and preferably dismantling the existing nuclear industry.
    It’s a difficult choice and will lead to hardship but it really is the only choice that gives people a real opportunity for a future.
    I am not optimistic that societies will go the route of hardship, for many reasons.
    Cognitive dissonance is too strong and the easy life of today is an addictive narcotic.
    As I approach 70 and having made a choice early in life to not have children, it is easier for me to see what’s the inevitable outcome of this modern life of ease and convenience.
    BTW, I am composing this note conveniently on my android phone. Let us hope that Fate is kind.

    • Cynic says:

      Friends are having babies, and fantasising about their as yet unproven capacities and simply wonderful futures, and I find it rather hard to join in, but one has to humour them – it’s part of the programming, and always has been.

      Nature itself will dismantle this poisonous – and poisoning civilization – whatever we choose to do or not do.

  2. Sheila Chambers says:

    What most people fail to realize is that high tech “renewables” which many expect to take over from fossil RESOURCES are as tightly tied to OIL as is any other technology we use today & that includes nuclear reactors.
    Our cars, trucks, trains & planes, all manufacturing other than small craft shops are also tied to fossil RESOURCES & we cannot replace a RESOURCE with an TECHNOLOGY that’s also DEPENDENT upon that same resource.
    The day is coming when the blackouts will be permenent, some individuals will still have electricity but only for as long as their “renewables” & their BATTERIES can be maintained then it’s lights out for them as well.
    They are going to be very disappointed when they discover that no, “renewables” cannot manufacture more “renewables” without the use of fossil resources for both their raw materials & energy.
    Those who survive the collapse of our civilization had better be prepared for a world without electricity or high tech devices that are tied to fossil resources.
    It will again be a world made by hand.

    • hugh owens says:

      Excellent comment as per your usual level of expertise, Sheila. My slight quibble is your use of the term resource when you mean reserve. This is commonly misstated all over the internet especially if the person misstating it does it deliberately as part of their agenda which is obviously not your agenda. A reserve is a resource which can be utilized economically. I really think a better term to avoid confusing the issue is “reserve resource”. All of the critical non renewable renewable resources present in the earths crust available to power the industrial civilization exist as resources but unless they are economically available, their utility is nil.

      • Sheila Chambers says:

        I was taught that raw materials were a “resource,” those were the raw materials we used to make what we need or want & a “reserve” was something kept for later but still accessable kind of like the wild lands we hold in reserve.
        We call all elements, minerals, ores, wild plants, wild fish, wild animals a “resource” but we can’t access or catch all of them can we?

        Another thing that has bothered me for a long time is how we claim to “harvest” wild animals & plants we had nothing to do with producing? How can we “harvest” what we haven’t “sown” or cared for?

        We harvest wheat rice & maize because we developed them from wild plants, selected & planted the seeds from the plants that had what we wanted, cared for them then harvested the results of our labors.

        I’ve also noticed how those “reserves” can expand or contract according to their price verses the cost of extracting them.

        So if we can find & extract it, it’s a “reserve” if your talking about the entire resource, that includes the raw materials we can’t access.

        No wonder “they” prefer to talk about our vast RESOURCES but omit how little of that is accessible as reserves.
        Do I get it now? do I get a cookie?

        So those who claim we will “never run out of X” are right in a way, we will always have resources left alone because the cost of finding them, extracting them or hunting them down has become too expensive & for many important reserves , that time has arrived.
        Frackers have been losing money for years, how much longer can they hang on?
        The price of a barrel of oil must rise for those “producers” to survive, but then if people can’t afford the higher prices, those “producers” will not make a profit & will eventually go out of business as so many frackers all ready have.
        The “writting” is on the “wall” in flames, why are so many people still ignoring it?
        My “agenda” as you suspect is just to wake some people up to the delema we’re in, not to claim we have unlimited reserved (accessable) resources.

        Perhaps Trump is right, it’s too late to save ourselves so PARTY ON, PETAL TO THE METAL, let’s use up this poor, abused planet so “Jesus” will come again & rapture the believers up into the sky where they will quickly die from freezing, solar radiation & anoxia.
        Sorry, I just couldn’t resist that!
        As for me, I prefer a 45 cal solution to collapse.

        • Cynic says:

          An old problem of terminology: the Mongols and other nomads talked about the ‘harvesting’ of the people they conquered and raided, as slaves….

  3. hugh owens says:

    All excellent points Sheila especially your point about fluctuating prices of a reserve that is economically available. You hit upon the etymological issue which is at the heart of my comment. A reserve is a resource which has been mined or can be, in known explored or utilized geological formations. It’s there, we know about how much and we can dig or mine it if the price is at least X on this specific date. If the price declines to say .5X tomorrow the reserve shrinks not because the quantity has shrunk but because the profitability has and many factors influence profitability such as wages and overhead,debt service,political factors. cost of energy etc. That’s is why the guvmunt or related agencies like the SEC or USGS like periodic estimates every year or so based upon whether it is economic on that particular date and the cost in energy terms is the main variable. Cheap available energy makes for big reserve estimates in many cases for the 85 or 90 most important non renewable “resources”.This point is often glossed over by the media and the analysts who need to keep the good news coming because they want to keep their jobs. Who wants to be told that their global industrial lifestyle will have a sell by date and is killing the planet to boot?Who wants to be told that suburbia is a doomed stranded asset, that in the very near future you will have to grow and prepare your own food?There is no green solution to this predicament of overshoot. Collapse is baked in to this cake and a new paradigm will hopefully arise from the ashes, emphasizing hard work, cooperation and trust and faith in the new system but that fact that this country is populated by ignorant, obese, depressed and angry deplorables doesn’t bode well for the immediate future.That .45 might come in handy but keep in mind the desperate guy next door might have a .46.

    • Sheila Chambers says:

      Another excellent, INFORMATIVE post by Hugh Owens, thank you!
      I’m living in fundamentalist Trump land & it’s good to find someone intelligent to converse with who GETS IT!
      Such people are rare in Trumps ‘merica.

      The guy with the “46” had better have his finger on the trigger & the hammer back or I will get him first! Is there such a thing as as 46cal gun?
      You don’t need a bigger gun, you just need to be faster & more accurate than the other person.

      People think I’m a whack job with a tin foil hat when I try to explain just how much trouble we are in, the word “finite” doesn’t seen to register with them & they firmly BELIEVE that “renewables” or some new technology will get us out of the hole we have dug for ourselves & keep digging ever deeper. Those EV’s won’t be of much use if you can’t RECHARGE that battery & what about FOOD?

      Those pushing “renewables” overlook the fact that they don’t produce any of the essential raw materials we now get from fossil reserves, things like FERTILIZER & fuel for our agricultural system, so they might still have their lights on but their fridge will be empty!

      Being a female usually means people think your ignorant & stupid & thus can be IGNORED.

      That HUGE “reserve” of oil off the Cali coast has quickly disappeared & we hear nothing more about it, same for that HUGE pre salt “reserve” off the coast of Brazil, crickets. The geology was too difficult & thus too expensive to extract so it will remain a resource we cannot access.
      The rising cost of resources will also put a drag on our ability to extract more reserves & that will put a crimp on much of our manufacturing, agriculture & our immoral, illegal, military adventures.
      I’m sure our RULERS know this & that’s why the frantic effort to find & extract more reserves any where in the world they can find it, the arctic, the antarctic, your back yard, no place with potential for PROFITS will go undrilled.
      “They” know that as we fail to meet our energy needs, things will fall apart & the last thing we need are thousands of poor, needy people with their hands out expecting us to provide them with a “better life” than our own poor, homeless & unemployed.
      Most of them are young males who want our jobs, most of them are not really “asylum seekers” their economic migrants, their fleeing povery.

      These desperate people are NOT “terrorist”, “criminals” “alien invaders” or “rapist” but I’m sure there are a FEW of those mingled in with them, but we cannot let them in, I don’t think we should be shooting them with live ammo either! But it could come to that.
      Just don’t allow them to get our jobs, our housing, our education or our chinsy social benefits & they will have to leave or starve/freeze to death like our own poor, jobless & homeless are now.

      The UN said we have POVERTY here as bad as any they have seen in third world countries so lets help them before we bring in more poor, needy people.
      Why not train some of them to do our agricultural work?

      I’m glad I’m OLD, at 78 I don’t have much time left, I feel sorry for the young who see where we are headed, they will be very ANGRY at what my generation & those before me did to this unique, beautiful planet & how we WASTED our resources.
      We cannot “terriform” mars, we cannot “spread out into the universe,” we evolved here & we will go extinct here, there is no escape.
      Still no “cookie”?

      • Cynic says:

        Don’t worry Sheila: it might be that as a woman you are ignored, but as a man, one gets treated warily as a (possibly dangerous?) nutter, or someone who simply ‘reads too much’ !!! ‘You read too much, that’s your problem!’ So much for civilisation.

        So, quite frankly, I don’t raise these issues with anyone anymore and do my best to seem ‘normal’ and ‘positive’ ….