What percent of Americans are rational?

Preface. Why does rationality matter — what’s the harm in believing there’s a fat “Santa Claus” God in the sky noting down every time any intelligent creature in the entire universe is naughty or nice on the trillions of inhabited planets in the universe every second of every day for eternity?

There’d be no harm if only fundamentalist groups believing in such things and their consequent strict rules didn’t feel compelled to make the rest of us believe and behave as they do. Some would not allow music, dancing, keep women completely covered and restrict them to cooking and child care, and ban all books but the Bible. Crazy as it sounds, there are Christians who want to bring Jesus back ASAP based on strange interpretations of Revelations and the best-selling books about the Rapture, even if it takes nuclear weapons to hasten it.

In the USA, Andersen (2017) estimates that only a third of us are more or less solidly reality-based. Or perhaps less: One poll concludes that only 27% of us are rational. And only 28% scientifically literate (Meinwald 2010). And even that may be optimistic — there isn’t a single survey that covers paranormal, supernatural, and basic knowledge of the world such as the National Science Foundation basic knowledge of the world, which found 26% of Americans think the sun revolves around the Earth, and only 48% of them in evolution (human beings developed from earlier species of animals).

With peak oil in 2018, six of the 9 boundaries breached that could drive us extinct, and all the other myriad overshoot factors of topsoil and aquifer depletion, bioinvasion, pesticides not working and more, we desperately need rationality and scientific literacy to cope with the hard times ahead. But the large minority that finds meaning in hate, guns (400 million of them!), literal translation of the Bible, uneducated, and more doesn’t bode well….

Some good news: 2023 As organized religion falters, the Devil falls on hard times. A new Gallup report that found more than half of Americans (58%) believe the devil exists, down from over two-thirds (68%) in 2001. About the same percentage (59%) said they believe in hell, down from 71% two decades ago. Belief in God dropped from 90% in 2001 to 74% in 2023. Belief in heaven went down from 83% to 67%, while belief in angels dropped from 79% to 69%. About 1 in 3 Americans claim no religion. Republicans and those earning less than $40,000 were more likely to believe in God, the Devil, and Hell.

Alice Friedemann www.energyskeptic.com Author of Life After Fossil Fuels: A Reality Check on Alternative Energy; When Trucks Stop Running: Energy and the Future of Transportation”, Barriers to Making Algal Biofuels, & “Crunch! Whole Grain Artisan Chips and Crackers”. Women in ecology Podcasts: WGBH, Financial Sense, Jore, Planet: Critical, Crazy Town, Collapse Chronicles, Derrick Jensen, Practical Prepping, Kunstler 253 &278, Peak Prosperity, Index of best energyskeptic posts

***

In a really strict sense none of us are 100% rational due to cognitive biases, framing effects, fallacies and so on (wiki lists over 250 of these). To be human is to be irrational. But we’re all capable of improving our critical thinking skills and our understanding of the world.

So I’ll stick with the paranormal, pseudoscience, scientific knowledge, and conspiracy beliefs.

A Gallup poll in 2005 found that “Three in four Americans believe in Paranormal”, and found that 73% believe in one or more of these: ESP, Haunted Houses, Ghosts, Telepathy, Clairvoyance, Astrology, communication with the dead is possible, Witches, reincarnation, Channeling. Only 27% of Americans thought none of them were true.

And it might have been even lower if irrational beliefs had been expanded to include conspiracy theories, scientific understanding, evolution, climate change, creationism, the Devil, Hell, angels, miracles, and other beliefs.

Paranormal and supernatural beliefs.

Multiple numbers reflect results from several surveys:

Angels: 77%, 72%, 72% 88% of Christians, 95% of evangelical Christians
Astrology: 25%, 26%, 29%
Channeling: 9%
Civil war wasn’t about slavery but states’ rights: 48%
Climate Change not due to man-made activities: 40%
Clairvoyance: 26%
Communication with the dead is possible: 21%
Creationism: 36%
Devil: 61%, 60%, 58%
ESP: 41%
Ghosts: 34%, 42%, 42%
Haunted Houses: 37%
Heaven: 71%, 75%
Hell: 64%, 61%
Jesus born of a virgin: 73%, 61%, 57%
Jesus is God or son of God: 73%, 68%
Jesus’s resurrection: 70%, 65%
Life after death: 71%, 64%
Miracles: 76%, 72%
Reincarnation: 21%, 20%, 24%
Sun revolves around the Earth: 25%
Telepathy: 31%
UFOs: 34%, 32%, 36%, extraterrestrial beings have visited 24%
Vaccines cause autism: 56%
Witches: 21%, 23%, 26%

Conspiracy theories (Chapman 2016)

So what is a conspiracy theory? It’s (1) a group (2) acting in secret (3) to alter institutions, usurp power, hide truth, or gain utility (4) at the expense of the common good.

There’s no way to stereotype people who believe conspiracy theories, they exist across gender, age, race, income, political affiliation, educational level and occupational status.

Education makes a difference though. 42% of those without a high school diploma had a high predisposition to conspiracies. A much lower, but still shockingly high 23% of those with postgraduate degrees also had a high disposition for conspiratorial beliefs (Uscinski 2014).

Only 26% of Americans disagreed with all 9 conspiracy theories below, and 33% even believed in a made-up conspiracy researchers called “The North Dakota Crash”. The percent who said that the government is concealing what they know about….

The 9/11 attacks 54.3%
The JFK assassination 49.6%
Alien encounters 42.6%
Global warming 42.1%
Plans for a one world government 32.9%
Obama’s birth certificate shows he’s a foreigner 30.2%
The origin of the AIDs virus 20.1%
Death of supreme court justice Scalia 27.8%
The moon landing 24.2%

People who believed in the highest number of conspiracies are also more likely to believe that “The World Will End in My Lifetime” (uh-oh, those evangelists again), as well as more likely to be fearful of government, less trusting of other people, and more likely to take actions such as buying a gun to overcome their fears.

Republicans are more likely to believe in conspiracies than democrats (Orth 2023)

Conspiracy	Definitely or Probably true	Not Sure	Definitely or probably False	Democrat	Republican
Lee Harvey Oswald did not act alone in assassinating John F. Kennedy in 1963	54	24	23	40	68
Regardless of who is officially in charge of the government and other organizations, there is a single group of people who secretly control events and rule the world together	41	15	44	28	60
Barack Obama was not born in the United States	31	19	50	15	54
Voting machines were programmed to change votes in the 2020 election	29	20	51	13	53
Many top Democrats are involved in child sex-trafficking rings	29	17	54	14	42
The U.S. has been developing bioweapons in biolabs throughout Ukraine	27	28	46	13	34
Many top Republicans are involved in child sex-trafficking rings	25	19	56	28	17
Vaccines have been shown to cause autism	24	23	53	13	36
Mass shootings have been faked by groups trying to promote stricter gun control laws	23	13	64	11	35
The U.S. government was behind the 9/11 attacks on New York City	20	14	66	17	21
The U.S. government is using the COVID-19 vaccine to microchip the population	20	13	66	14	28
The 1969 landing on the moon didn’t occur and was actually staged somewhere in Arizona	18	17	65	13	26

Religious fundamentalists and dogmatic individuals are more likely to believe fake news

New research provides evidence that delusion-prone individuals, dogmatic individuals, and religious fundamentalists are more likely to believe fake news. The study, which appears in the Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition, suggests that the inability to detect false information is related to a failure to be actively open-minded.

“Previous research has shown that individuals who engage in less analytic thinking may be more likely to believe fake news. Our study extends this previous work in two ways. First, it shows that individuals who engage in less actively open-minded thinking may also be more likely to believe fake news,” Bronstein explained.

“Second, it suggests that reduced engagement in actively open-minded and analytic thinking might explain belief in fake news among individuals who endorse delusion-like ideas, dogmatic individuals, and religious fundamentalists. These results suggest that it might be possible to reduce belief in fake news using interventions that may increase analytic or actively open-minded thinking.”

National Science Foundation Questions 2014

The questions below are followed by correct answer and the percent who got it right:

The center of the Earth is very hot. True 84%
The continents have been moving their location for millions of years and will continue to move. True 83%
Does the Earth go around the sun, or does the sun go around the Earth? Earth around sun 74%
All radioactivity is man-made. True or false? False 72%
Electrons are smaller than atoms. True or false? True 53%
Lasers work by focusing sound waves. True or false? False 47%
The universe began with a huge explosion. True or false? True 39%
It’s the father’s gene that decides whether the baby is a boy or girl. True or false? True 63%
Antibiotics kill viruses as well as bacteria. True or false? False 51%
Human beings, as we know them today, developed from earlier species of animals. True or false? True 48%

Not surprisingly, the higher the education level the greater the number of correct answers.

2016-3-30 Depressing Survey Results Show How Extremely Stupid America Has Become

American Council of Trustees and Alumni:

Nearly 10% of college graduates thought TV’s “Judge Judy,” was a member of the U.S. Supreme Court.
Less than 20% of college graduates knew the effect of the Emancipation Proclamation.
More than a quarter of the college graduates did not know Franklin D. Roosevelt was president during World War II; one-third did not know he was the president who spearheaded the New Deal.
Newsweek. Of 1,000 U.S. citizens who took America’s official citizenship test:
29% couldn’t name the vice president
73% couldn’t correctly say why we fought the Cold War
44% were unable to define the Bill of Rights
6% couldn’t circle Independence Day on a calendar

And much more, go to the link above to see the full depressing story.

The world

Below is a poll of over 17,000 adults all over the world (Ipsos 2017) asking if they think that Religion does more harm in the world than good. In my opinion, YES, DOES MORE HARM is a sign of rationality. If you do too, then the rational nations are: Belgium, Germany, Spain, Australia, India, Sweden, Great Britain, France, Canada, Hungary, Argentina, Poland, Italy, Serbia, Mexico, and Turkey. All of these 15 nations who scored higher than the U.S. But congratulations to the 44% of Americans who answered correctly.

Related Posts:

Critical Thinking

Posts showing good critical thinking

Surveys, references

Andersen, K. 2017. Fantasyland. How America Went Haywire. A 500-Year History. Random House.

AP / GFK. December 8-12, 2011. Poll in 2011. Associated Press. 1,000 interviews. Error: +/- 4%

Baylor. 2017. American values, mental health, and using technology in the age of trump. Baylor religion survey.

Chapman. October 11, 2016. What aren’t they telling us? Chapman University Survey of American Fears.

Gallup. 2005. Paranormal beliefs come (Super)naturally to some.

Gallup. 2005. Three in Four Americans believe in Paranormal.

Gallup. 2016. Most Americans still believe in God.

Harris Poll. 2009. What People Do and do not believe in.

Harris Poll. 2013. What do Americans Believe?

IPSOS. July 2017. Ipsos global poll: Two in three Australians think religion does more harm than good in the world.

Johnson, D. 2016. The Making of Donald Trump. Penguin.

Meinwald J et al (2010) Chapter 12: The conceptualization and measurement of civic scientific literacy for the twenty-first century. American Academy of Arts & Sciences.

National Science Foundation. 2015. Belief in the Paranormal or pseudoscience. Science and technology: public attitudes and public understand.

Orth T (2023) Which conspiracy theories do Americans believe? today.yougov.com

Politico. August 3, 2017. How the CIA Came to Doubt the Official Story of JFK’s Murder Newly released documents from long-secret Kennedy assassination files raise startling questions about what top agency officials knew and when they knew it. Politico.com.

Reardon 2016. Reardon, S. October 18, 2016. The scientists who support Donald Trump. Nature.

Uscinski, J.E., et al. 2014. American Conspiracy Theories. Oxford University Press.