Are Republicans trying to foment a revolution by cutting off SNAP benefits?

Preface. Cutting off food aid to about 5 million people, over 1.2 million of them children, ought to be a crime.  Apparently Republicans are unaware of the phrase “only 9 meals away from a revolution.” Hunger was the main reason for the French revolution and many others:

  • The Russian Revolution 1917 Severe wartime winter weather choked railway supply lines. Cities faced catastrophic bread shortages, leading to “Bread Riots” in Petrograd. Overthrow of Tsar Nicholas II; end of the Russian Empire and rise of the Soviet Union.
  • The Arab Spring 2010–2011 Intense droughts in Russia and China in 2010 caused global wheat prices to spike. Bread prices doubled in places like Egypt. Toppling of dictators in Tunisia, Egypt, and Libya; sparked the Syrian Civil War.
  • The European Revolutions of 1848 The “Hungry Forties” saw widespread potato blight (across Europe, not just Ireland) and poor grain harvests, driving up food prices. Over 50 countries experienced uprisings demanding constitutional governments and worker rights.
  • The Fall of the Ming Dynasty 1644 The Little Ice Age brought severe droughts, locust plagues, and famine across China, leaving the government unable to provide relief. Collapse of the Ming Dynasty after a peasant rebellion captured Beijing, leading to the Qing Dynasty.
  • The Haitian Revolution 1791 While rooted in the brutality of slavery, the plantation system prioritized cash crops (sugar/coffee) over food, leaving enslaved populations perpetually malnourished and desperate. Defeat of French colonial rule; creation of the world’s first free Black republic.

Turchin, who has studied patterns in the rise and fall of civilizations throughout history, found that immiseration of the population was a common theme. It is certainly happening here in America, the richest country that has ever or will ever exist, with 43 million people, 13% of U.S. population, needing food aid?   And they are working hard. According to the U.S. Census bureau “More than three-quarters of those families had at least one person working and about one-third included two or more workers…”

The Trump administration claims there is fraud, but it is trivial compared to what the wealthy steal. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) estimates an average tax noncompliance rate of 18.3% for tax years 2008 through 2010, a $458 billion loss to the federal government.  Most of the fraud today is skimming of SNAP benefit cards and thieves spending all the money on the card, leaving the poor with no food aid for that month. Nor does the government do much to prevent this.

About 70% of the $1.4 trillion dollar Farm Bill is for SNAP benefits, which the farmers don’t like. But farmers get a tremendous amount of aid from other funding (Smith 2026, USDA 2026).

Below are excerpts from 5 different government documents on the SNAP program (formerly the food stamp program) about getting rid of fraud. Some excerpts:

  • During economic downturns, every $1 issued in SNAP benefits generates up to $1.80 in economic activity. Every time a family or individual uses SNAP benefits to put food on the table, it benefits the store and the employees where the purchase was made, the truck driver who delivered the food, the warehouses that stored it, the plant that processed it, and the farmer who produced the food. In short, SNAP strengthens individuals, their families, and their communities.
  • SNAP also operates with efficiency. Almost 95% of Federal SNAP spending goes directly to families to buy food. Most of the rest goes toward the Federal share of State administrative costs. Only a small portion goes to Federal administration, including oversight of State operations and monitoring of retailers that accept SNAP. Relative to other federal means-tested programs, SNAP spends far less on program administration.

With climate change, farmers will need more and more aid, and more and more people will need SNAP until the whole system snaps from energy and resource decline.  Is this is one of the ways the Republicans are trying to deal with collapse?

Alice Friedemann  www.energyskeptic.com  Author of Life After Fossil Fuels: A Reality Check on Alternative Energy; When Trucks Stop Running: Energy and the Future of Transportation”, Barriers to Making Algal Biofuels, & “Crunch! Whole Grain Artisan Chips and Crackers”, The Preservation of Knowledge, Women in ecology  Podcasts: WGBH, Financial Sense, Jore, Planet: Critical, Crazy Town, Collapse Chronicles, Derrick Jensen, Practical Prepping, Kunstler 253 &278, Peak Prosperity,  Index of best energyskeptic posts

***

Statement of Kevin W. Concannon, Under Secretary for the Food, Nutrition and Consumer Services Before the House Subcommittees on Government Operations and Interior June 9, 2016

Kevin W. Concannon: The program currently provides food assistance, nutrition education and work support services to 44.3 million low-income individuals according to the most recent month of data. In Fiscal Year (FY) 2014, 64% percent of SNAP recipients were children, seniors, and those with disabilities and 42% of SNAP participants lived in a household with a working adult. In other words, the vast majority of recipients are people who already work or, because of age or disability, are not expected to work.

In contrast to commonly heard rhetoric, SNAP does have work requirements. In general, those who are able to work must register to do so, they must accept a job if offered, and they may not voluntarily quit or reduce work hours in order to become eligible for or continue receiving SNAP. This requirement is not waivable. Those who violate the work requirements face sanctions and may be permanently disqualified from SNAP. In FY 2015, 13.6 million SNAP recipients were registered for work. SNAP’s Employment and Training (E&T) program helps participants prepare for and secure good paying jobs, serving about 600,000 SNAP participants in FY 2014 and more than 1 million participants in FY 2015. USDA continues to expand its capacity to administer the SNAP E&T program nationally and work with States to strengthen their programs to help more SNAP participants gain skills and find work. FNS recently established the Office of Employment and Training to better target E&T resources to the most effective strategies.

During economic downturns, every $1 issued in SNAP benefits generates up to $1.80 in economic activity. Every time a family or individual uses SNAP benefits to put food on the table, it benefits the store and the employees where the purchase was made, the truck driver who delivered the food, the warehouses that stored it, the plant that processed it, and the farmer who produced the food. In short, SNAP strengthens individuals, their families, and their communities.

SNAP also operates with efficiency. Almost 95% of Federal SNAP spending goes directly to families to buy food. Most of the rest goes toward the Federal share of State administrative costs. Only a small portion goes to Federal administration, including oversight of State operations and monitoring of retailers that accept SNAP. Relative to other federal means-tested programs, SNAP spends far less on program administration.

On the Federal side, we establish rules and regulations, provide monitoring and oversight of State administration of the program, pay the full cost of SNAP benefits ($69.7 billion for FY 2015),

USDA takes the lead on the authorization, monitoring and oversight of stores that redeem SNAP benefits—over 260,000 stores around the country.

Punishments can include permanent disqualification and even prosecution.

According to the latest data available, in FY 2015 when more than 45.7 million people participated in the program, States conducted approximately 723,000 investigations resulting in over 46,500 disqualifications for recipient fraud and collected almost $86 million in fraud claims from households. The FNS has succeeded in reducing trafficking from about 4% to 1.3% over the last 20 years. While the trafficking rate is low, and 98.7% of the benefits are used properly, we continue to focus on this vital area because, when almost $70 billion (in FY 2015) in taxpayer supported benefits are involved, continuous attention, energy and diligence is required.

Statement of Mike Carroll Secretary, Florida Department of Children and Families “SNAP: Examining Efforts to Combat Fraud and Improve Program Integrity” Committee on Oversight and Government Reform Subcommittees for Government Operations and The Interior June 9, 2016

I am proud of what Florida has accomplished, and I have a unique and firsthand perspective on it. I started with the Florida Department of Children and Families more than 26 years ago helping people with their eligibility applications. Back then, applications were still on paper, and filled out with a pencil. On the days after it rained, lines would wrap around the building. Applicants had to come in sometimes multiple times to provide interviews and ensure their applications were submitted correctly. It was, of course, inefficient for everyone involved, but it was the best we could do at the time. Modernization Today, Florida is a leader in the modernization of our social services system, and virtually every state in the nation has come to Florida to study our model.

Our efforts have led to a nearly 100 percent accuracy rate on applications, with 93 percent being submitted online, allowing us to reduce our eligibility staff from 7,000 to 4,000. Over the years, our cost per eligibility transaction has dropped from $30 to $7. Our experience in Florida is a testament to how government can run an operation that is cost-effective, efficient and optimizes access to services in a simplified way for customers.

However, we have a new fight on our hands with a growing epidemic of identity theft and trafficking. We are not talking about “mom and pop” storefront operations or cottage industries. We are talking about major criminal enterprises with ties to other serious and dangerous criminal activities including drug sales, prostitution and human trafficking.

In Florida, we have implemented effective front-end detection systems and common-sense legislation that addresses obvious fraud and abuse at the roots. We have banned EBT card transactions at all adult entertainment and gambling venues and in the purchase of alcohol, created a fraud reward program, enhanced criminal penalties for fraud, and revised the definition of EBT trafficking in Florida law to include swapping food benefits for weapons or controlled substances. In addition, our Office of Public Benefits Integrity last year conducted more than 23,000 investigations resulting in more than $27.6 million in cost avoidance.

Florida was the first state in the nation to partner with the Food and Nutrition Service in the battle to combat ID theft.  The current burden of proof for recipient fraud is “clear and convincing,” which is a higher burden of proof than for retailer fraud. We should reduce the burden of proof for recipient fraud to “preponderance of evidence.” Right now it is easier to arrest a recipient than to disqualify them from the SNAP program. When it comes to retailer fraud, we need a bigger army and more cohesive approach. 1. The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Office of Inspector General has sole authority to investigate retailer fraud, yet has 1/10th of the resources in Florida as the Health and Human Services’ Office of Inspector General. 2. FNS needs to immediately suspend a SNAP Authorized Retailer upon criminal arrest. 3. We need stronger federal policies to require repayment from retailers. Currently, retailers rarely are required to repay trafficked amounts in administrative sanctions. We need to send a strong message that fraud will not be tolerated.

Opa Locka The largest food stamp trafficking bust in the federal program’s history occurred just last month at a flea market in South Florida. It was great work, but it also demonstrates how much more work we need to do. Operation Stampede so far has resulted in the arrests of 22 owners of SNAP authorized retailers and uncovered – just for the past year – $17 million in fraud.

Officers found thousands of dollars in cash and guns, storefronts that were actually drug sale operations, and human trafficking and prostitution. Also uncovered were empty storage rooms, unsanitary conditions, rotten produce, empty display boxes, and even plastic fruit and vegetables on display. One store owner was an illegal alien who used someone else’s Social Security Number to get FNS authorization. Another owner was here on a work permit. And yet another failed to disclose they were a convicted felon.

Since 2011, there has been nearly $89 million in SNAP transactions at this location. We now have to look at more than 41,000 authorized SNAP recipients just since July – and that number is growing – to find cases that might rise to the level of “clear and convincing evidence.” And, the trafficking has not stopped. Today, there are at least eight authorized retailers with transactions consistent with the pattern of fraudulent activity for which this location is now well known. In the first two weeks following the raid, these stores had over $163,000 in SNAP redemptions involving over 1,100 recipients.

 

United States Government Accountability Office Testimony Before the Subcommittees on Government Operations and the Interior, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, House of Representatives.  SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM Enhanced Detection Tools and Reporting to Combat Recipient Fraud Are in Development Statement of Kay E. Brown, Director Education, Workforce, and Income Security Issues GAO-16-719T

SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM Enhanced Detection Tools and Reporting to Combat Recipient Fraud Are in Development Why GAO Did This Study In fiscal year 2015, SNAP, the nation’s largest nutrition support program, provided about 46 million people with $70 billion in benefits. Fraud has been a long-standing concern in the program,

What GAO Found.  In 2014, GAO found that selected states employed a range of tools to detect potential Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) recipient fraud, but they faced challenges, including inadequate staffing levels, that limited the effectiveness of their actions, and the Food and Nutrition Service (FNS) lacked data about the states’ efforts. The 11 states GAO studied reported using detection tools required or recommended by FNS, among others, to combat SNAP recipient fraud. However, 8 of these states reported difficulties in conducting fraud investigations due to reduced or stagnant staff levels and funding despite program growth, and some state officials suggested changing the financial incentives structure to help support the costs of investigating potential fraud.

GAO found FNS’s recommended website monitoring tools to be less effective than manual searches and impractical for detecting internet posts indicative of SNAP trafficking—the misuse of program benefits to obtain non-food items. Further, although FNS required states to monitor SNAP households that request at least four replaced electronic benefit transfer (EBT) cards in a year, GAO found that multiple EBT card requests in the same benefit period may not indicate increased risk of trafficking. GAO found that, by adjusting the analysis to focus on SNAP households that both requested cards in at least four different monthly benefit periods and engaged in suspicious transactions, states could possibly detect potential fraud more accurately. For example, in 2014, GAO found that 4,935 SNAP households in Michigan received at least 4 replaced EBT cards in a year. However, out of these householders, GAO identified 39 households that both received multiple replacement cards in at least four different monthly benefit periods and engaged in suspicious transactions indicative of SNAP trafficking, resulting in 10 or more trafficking flags. GAO reported that this type of targeted analysis may help provide states with a starting point for identifying higher priority households for further review, which can be particularly helpful given that states had reported having limited resources for conducting investigations.

In fiscal year 2015, the federal government provided more than $70 billion in benefits to help about 46 million people purchase food through SNAP. On average, recipient households received about $258 a month in assistance in that year.

FNS program officials have had long-standing concerns that some recipients can falsify information to receive benefits, or misuse their benefits to solicit or obtain non-food goods, services and cash—a practice known as trafficking.

The goal of SNAP, formerly known as the federal Food Stamp Program, is to help low-income individuals and households obtain a more nutritious diet and help alleviate their hunger. It does so by supplementing their income with benefits to purchase allowable food items. The federal government pays the full cost of the benefits and shares the responsibility and costs of administering the program with the states. Specifically, FNS is responsible for promulgating program regulations and ensuring that states comply with these regulations by issuing guidance and monitoring their state activity. FNS headquarters officials are assisted in this oversight work by federal officials in seven regional offices. FNS also determines which retailers are eligible to accept SNAP benefits in exchange for food and investigates and resolves cases of retailer fraud. State officials, on the other hand, are responsible for determining the eligibility of individuals and households, calculating the amount of their monthly benefits and issuing such benefits on an electronic benefit transfer (EBT) card in accordance with program rules.

Trafficking is an intentional program violation that includes acts of fraud, such as making false or misleading statements in order to obtain benefits and trafficking (i.e., using benefits in unallowable ways, such as by exchanging benefits for cash or non-food goods and services or attempting to do so).8 For example, recipients can traffic benefits by selling EBT cards to another person, exchanging the EBT card and the corresponding Personal Identification Number (PIN)9 for cash or non-food goods or services (e.g., rent or transportation). These sales can occur in person or by posting offers on social media and e-commerce sites. Recipients can then contact state agencies to report the sold EBT cards as lost or stolen and receive new cards which can be used for future trafficking transactions, for example, when the benefits are replenished the next month.

 

SNAP: Combating Fraud and Improving Program Integrity Without Weakening Success Testimony of Stacy Dean, Vice President for Food Assistance Policy, Center on Budget and Policy

On average, SNAP recipients receive about $1.39 per person per meal in food benefits. One in seven Americans is participating in SNAP — a figure that speaks both to the extensive need across our country and to SNAP’s important role in addressing it.

Policymakers created SNAP to help low-income families and individuals purchase an adequate diet. It does an admirable job of providing poor households with basic nutritional support and has largely eliminated severe hunger and malnutrition in the United States.

When the program was first established, hunger and malnutrition were much more serious problems in this country than they are today. A team of Field Foundation-sponsored doctors who examined hunger and malnutrition among poor children in the South, Appalachia, and other very poor areas in 1967 (before the Food Stamp Program, as SNAP was then named, was widespread in these areas) and again in the late 1970s (after the program had been instituted nationwide) found marked reductions over this ten-year period in serious nutrition-related problems among children. The doctors gave primary credit for this reduction to the Food Stamp Program. Findings such as this led then-Senator Robert Dole to describe the Food Stamp Program as the most important advance in the nation’s social programs since the creation of Social Security.

During the recession, as the official poverty rate rose from 12.5 percent to 15.1 percent, SNAP enrollment rose to respond to this increase. Poverty stayed high through 2014 (the most recent year for which data are available), at 14.8 percent,

Participation rates among eligible people grew from 69 percent in 2007 to 83 percent in 2014 (the most recent year available). Several factors likely contributed to these rising rates. The widespread and prolonged effects of the recession, particularly the record long-term unemployment, may have made it more difficult for family members and communities to help people struggling to make ends meet.

Long-term unemployment hit record highs in the recession and remains unusually high; in May 2016, about a quarter (25.1 percent) of the nation’s 7.4 million unemployed workers had been looking for work for 27 weeks or longer. That’s much higher than it’s ever been (in data back to 1948) when overall unemployment has been so low.

The percentage of SNAP benefit dollars issued to ineligible households or to eligible households in excessive amounts fell for seven consecutive years and stayed low in 2014 at 2.96 percent, USDA data show. The underpayment error rate also stayed low at 0.69 percent. The combined payment error rate — that is, the sum of the overpayment and underpayment error rates — was 3.66 percent, low by historical standards.5 Less than 1 percent of SNAP benefits go to households that are ineligible. (See Figure 7.) If one subtracts underpayments (which reduce federal costs) from overpayments, the net loss to the government in FY2014 from errors was 2.27 percent of benefits.

In comparison, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) estimates an average tax noncompliance rate of 18.3 percent for tax years 2008 through 2010 (the most recently studied years). This represents a $458 billion loss to the federal government in one year. Underreporting of business income alone cost the federal government an average of $125 billion per year between 2008 and 2010, and nonfarm sole proprietors underreport their income by 63 percent.

Internal Revenue Service, “Tax Gap for Tax Year 2008-2010, Overview,” April 28, 2016, https://www.irs.gov/PUP/newsroom/tax%20gap%20estimates%20for%202008%20through%202010.pdf

Low-income earners often experience sharp fluctuations in their monthly income, making household income difficult to predict accurately for SNAP benefit calculations. Some states instituted administrative practices designed to reduce errors that had the unintended effect of making it harder for many working-poor parents to participate, largely by requiring them to take too much time off from work for repeated visits to SNAP offices at frequent intervals, such as every 90 days, to reapply for benefits.

 

Statement of Mary Mayhew Commissioner, Maine Department of Health and Human Services SNAP: Examining Efforts to Combat Fraud and Improve Program Integrity The Government Oversight Committee Subcommittees for Government Operations and The Interior June 9, 2016

When Governor LePage took office in January 2011, Maine had a record 250,000 people on SNAP with annual expenditures on benefits of $330 million out of a population of 1.3 million people. To strengthen the program integrity of SNAP in the

In a recent case in Maine a 33 year old man was arrested in a drug raid that found crack cocaine, guns, cash and 5 EBT cards. The EBT cards were all in the name of someone other than drug dealer arrested. One of the cards issued had been re-issued to the recipient 47 times in a span of a few years. In another similar case last year in Maine a drug felon was accepting SNAP-loaded EBT cards as payment for the illicit drug Fentanyl, which is 50 times more potent than heroin and responsible for thousands of overdose deaths.1 We know there is a very unfortunate and direct connection between benefits trafficking and the drug-trafficking world, but federal SNAP regulations often create barriers to pursuing cases against these traffickers. FNS rules state categorically that if someone has the EBT card and the PIN, FNS considers them an authorized user of the EBT card. Law enforcement officials give us examples of persons arrested with drugs and EBT cards who tell them they are going grocery shopping for the person whose name is on the card. Because of the regulation, there is little we can do to stop that practice. The regulation should be changed to require authorized users to register as such with the welfare agency overseeing the program and should be limited to no more than three per case at any given time.2 This is similar to how the Woman, Infants and Children (WIC) program operates currently in Maine, which is also administered by Maine DHHS, and is permitted under federal regulation.

Another key strategy in Maine’s mission to deter welfare fraud has been to place photos on our EBT cards. This is a common sense measure that provides protection against trafficking or theft. When someone’s picture is on their card, it only follows that they are less likely to sell it for cash or trade it for drugs. We have seen the results – while EBT cards still turn up in drug-related arrests too often, we don’t see EBT cards with photos turning up in those raids.

In Maine, we have found that out of state usage of our EBT cards is a major warning sign of fraudulent activity. In 2011, Maine had more than $15 million in welfare benefits spent outside of Maine, including significant amounts in places like the Bronx, Brooklyn, Philadelphia and Worcester, Massachusetts.4 Our Law Enforcement partners informed us these are known drug trafficking cities, with heroin and other drugs flowing up the I-95 corridor to Maine. Our data analytics software alerts us when someone has used a Maine EBT card exclusively in other states for two consecutive months. We then follow up with the client to ensure there is no inappropriate use and that they still reside in Maine. By working with this EBT data extensively, we cracked down on inappropriate out of state welfare use. As a result, out of state usage of Maine EBT cards has been reduced to $8 million a year.

Unfortunately, the data still shows regular usage of SNAP benefits in places all over the country, like Brooklyn, New York, California and the Walt Disney World area of Florida. Federal regulations don’t currently allow states to restrict SNAP benefits to certain geographic areas. We don’t believe it is right for Maine SNAP benefits to be spent by someone living outside of Maine and we see the connection between interstate usage of EBT and fraud. We believe there should be some reasonable restrictions on the mobility of EBT cards.5

Retailer Fraud and Non-compliance Often when SNAP benefits cards are trafficked it is in conjunction with a SNAP approved vendor who is helping turn the card to cash that can be used to purchase things other than food. In some cases, the offending stores are small “convenience” type stores. There are many of these stores participating in the SNAP program that may not be meeting the goals of the “ nutrition” program based on their real food inventories. For example, in one Maine case of suspected retailer fraud this year, a small store with just one cash register had SNAP reimbursements totaling nearly that of a large local Hannaford chain grocery store with 18 cash registers. We were alerted to the potential fraud because our data tracking found numerous instances of $300 and above purchases in this small store that had no grocery carts to carry out that amount of produce. The same store is suspected of trading cash for EBT cards and helping SNAP participants commit tax fraud.

Retailer Oversight In the case that a store is committing fraud or is in non-compliance with food standards, states do not have the authority to remove them from SNAP participation. We rely on the federal government for that function. The investigator we have in our region does a great job, but we know that USDA is resource constrained in our region in terms of investigating and disqualifying offending stores. Only 8 stores in Maine have been sanctioned since 2011.

Welfare enrollment, particularly in SNAP, has had explosive growth since 2000. SNAP has grown from 17 million to 45 million people.10

Welfare fraud has followed the trend and in Maine we’ve seen a disturbing and strong connection to the drug problem. We can’t sit idly by as taxpayer funded programs help fuel the drug trade through trafficking or divert scarce resources away from hungry children and needy families. We have an obligation to deter fraud, protect benefits for the truly needy and secure taxpayer’s peace of mind that their money isn’t being wasted.

STATEMENT SECRETARIES’ INNOVATION GROUP

One out of every seven Americans currently receives Food Stamps. The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), which is known as Food Stamps, has quadrupled in cost since 2001, and has doubled in cost since President Obama took office in 2008. States face an uphill battle on reforming this program.

FOOD STAMP PROGRAM PROBLEMS AND RECOMMENDED SOLUTIONS 1) The “Nutrition” program allows the purchase of soda, candy and other harmful products PROBLEM: The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program is intended to subsidize nutrition for needy families. Instead it is fueling the Obesity problem in America. Too many recipients are utilizing their benefit to purchase items that are not only void of nutrition, they are damaging to their health. “More than one-third of adults and 17% of youth in the United States are obese,” according to the Journal of the American Medical Association.1 The Obesity epidemic, driven in part by poor choices in Food Stamp purchasing, costs the U.S. and states billions of dollars. According to a Health Affairs study, the medical costs associated with Obesity are an estimated $147 billion in 2008.2 This massive spending certainly includes state’s Medicaid programs, which is a major cost driver in state and federal budgets.

References

Smith VH et al (2026) Are US Farms Facing a Financial Crisis? aei.org

USDA (2026) Direct Government payments to U.S. farm producers, 2022–26F

Posted in Farming & Ranching, Poverty, Starvation | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Reforestation can reduce rivers and rainfall

Preface. We’ll need a lot of forests in the future when wood once again becomes our main source of energy and infrastructure as it was before fossil fuels. But planting more trees an backfire and have unintended consequences

Alice Friedemann  www.energyskeptic.com  Author of Life After Fossil Fuels: A Reality Check on Alternative Energy; When Trucks Stop Running: Energy and the Future of Transportation”, Barriers to Making Algal Biofuels, & “Crunch! Whole Grain Artisan Chips and Crackers”.  Women in ecology  Podcasts: WGBH, Financial Sense, Jore, Planet: Critical, Crazy Town, Collapse Chronicles, Derrick Jensen, Practical Prepping, Kunstler 253 &278, Peak Prosperity,  Index of best energyskeptic posts

***

2025 China Planted 78 Billion New Trees—and Seriously Messed Up Its Water Cycle. Popular Mechanics

China began growing the Three-North Shelterbelt, or “The Great Green Wall,” in 1978 as an effort to combat soil erosion and decrease desert storms. The project, the country’s state-sponsored media announced, was finally complete as of last year.

According to Reuters, China grew 116,000 square miles of trees, increasing the country’s total forest coverage from 10 percent in 1949 to roughly 25 percent in 2024. But a new study published in the journal Earth’s Future, shows that all those additional trees (roughly 78 billion since the early 80s, by some estimates) come with some unforeseen consequences for China’s water distribution.

between 2001 and 2020, increased vegetation reduced water resources in both the eastern monsoon region and the northwestern arid region. That’s a big deal, considering these areas make up roughly 74% of China’s total land area

According to the study, regreening efforts like the Great Green Wall—along with other tree-planting initiatives, such as Grain for Green Program and the Natural Forest Protection Program, with both started in 1999—have increased evapotranspiration, which is a portmanteau of evaporation and transpiration (the process through which plants release water vapor through tiny pores known as stomata).

“These shifts caused changes in precipitation, directing more moisture to the Tibetan Plateau, which saw an increase in water availability,” the authors wrote. “In contrast, eastern and northwestern China experienced a decrease in water availability, with the northwest losing the most due to substantial moisture moving to the Tibetan Plateau.”

China’s water availability isn’t conveniently distributed for its population. According to the study, the country’s northern regions contain roughly 46 percent of its population and more than half of the arable land, but only 20 percent of water availability.

 

Bentley, L., et al. 2020. Partial river flow recovery with forest age is rare in the decades following establishment. Global Change Biology.

River flow is reduced in areas where forests have been planted and does not recover over time, a new study has shown. Rivers in some regions can completely disappear within a decade. This highlights the need to consider the impact on regional water availability, as well as the wider climate benefit, of tree-planting plans.

“Reforestation is an important part of tackling climate change, but we need to carefully consider the best places for it. In some places, changes to water availability will completely change the local cost-benefits of tree-planting programmes,” said Laura Bentley, a plant scientist in the University of Cambridge Conservation Research Institute, and first author of the report.

Planting large areas of trees has been suggested as one of the best ways of reducing atmospheric carbon dioxide levels, since trees absorb and store this greenhouse gas as they grow. While it has long been known that planting trees reduces the amount of water flowing into nearby rivers, there has previously been no understanding of how this effect changes as forests age.

The study looked at 43 sites across the world where forests have been established, and used river flow as a measure of water availability in the region. It found that within five years of planting trees, river flow had reduced by an average of 25%. By 25 years, rivers had gone down by an average of 40% and in a few cases had dried up entirely. The biggest percentage reductions in water availability were in regions in Australia and South Africa.

“River flow does not recover after planting trees, even after many years, once disturbances in the catchment and the effects of climate are accounted for,” said Professor David Coomes, Director of the University of Cambridge Conservation Research Institute, who led the study.

Published in the journal Global Change Biology, the research showed that the type of land where trees are planted determines the degree of impact they have on local water availability. Trees planted on natural grassland where the soil is healthy decrease river flow significantly. On land previously degraded by agriculture, establishing forest helps to repair the soil so it can hold more water and decreases nearby river flow by a lesser amount.

Counterintuitively, the effect of trees on river flow is smaller in drier years than wetter ones. When trees are drought-stressed they close the pores on their leaves to conserve water, and as a result draw up less water from the soil. In wet weather the trees use more water from the soil, and also catch the rainwater in their leaves.

“Climate change will affect water availability around the world,” said Bentley. “By studying how forestation affects water availability, we can work to minimise any local consequences for people and the environment.”

 

Posted in Deforestation, Farming & Ranching, Wood | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

How concrete damages the planet by TC Fishman

Preface. This is one of the best articles I have seen in years on concrete – its climate effects, how it is made, and ways that it could be made that would emit less carbon dioxide. Biomass does not scale up, hydrogen and electricity are not mentioned, and carbon sequestration is only done when subsidized by governments and captures very little CO2. In the U.S. the Trump administration cancelled most Biden-era “Buy Clean” initiatives for reducing CO₂ emissions in federal construction projects and another $1.6 billion to develop the market in sustainable concrete.  What little CO2 is captured is valuable for the oil industry, one of the few that can use it, to produce even more oil by using CO2 to push it to the surface. Yet sequestration is the only way to reduce CO2 emissions for the foreseeable future. There are other materials that emit less carbon being experimented with, but the problem is, Portland Cement has proven itself for over 100 years and it will take decades or more for other options to convince builders to use alternatives. And it had better be cheaper.

There was no mention of using (renewable) electricity or hydrogen to replace fossil fuels in making cement.

Continue reading →

Posted in Concrete | Tagged , , | Comments Off on How concrete damages the planet by TC Fishman

The history of rope making

Preface.  Thousands of types of knots have been invented since rope was, I imagine that unless some books on this survive, that future generations will be busy reinventing what was once known in the past.  Rope was far more important than I’d realized to human civilization.

These are the incomplete, disjointed notes from my Kindle, so you will probably want to buy the book to have a complete, flowing narrative.   Alice Friedemann

***

Continue reading →

Posted in Agriculture | Tagged | Comments Off on The history of rope making

What will future societies be like after fossil fuels are gone?

Preface.  I was writing about how deadly and brutal wars are today, nuclear bombs, and all the mafia totalitarian and gangster states like Russia and Mexico, Ecuador, various African states that make the lives of their people miserable and getting pretty depressed.

Then I remembered this book by Vaclav Smil. Energy and Civilization A History (2017) MIT Press. In the future societies can’t get as bad — they won’t have the fossil energy to gain as much territory, power, and control.  Energy determines what societies are capable of.  The ability to make nuclear weapons, jet fighters, AI killing machines and more will no longer be possible.

Eventually societies will go back to wood for fuel, which limits the size of cities, which need at least 30 times as much woodlands surrounding them for energy to cook and heat with. Since it takes a lot of energy to get to a forest, cut it down, and take it back to a city, I think deforestation is more likely from forest fires than being cut down as the shift from fossils back to biomass is made.

Continue reading →

Posted in Agriculture, Vaclav Smil, War | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on What will future societies be like after fossil fuels are gone?

Phosphate: All hopes for food and LFP batteries rest on Morocco with up to 85% of remaining reserves

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is phosphorous-conveyer-belt-61-miles-long.jpg

Source: The world’s longest conveyor belt system of 61 miles to convey phosphate ore to the sea (atlasobscura.com)

Phosphate is absolutely essential for both plants and animals.  It’s estimated that Morocco has of 75-85% of phosphate reserves.

How long reserves will last depends on being economic. So if the price of oil rises too high or is scarce, reserves become resources again.As the best cheapest reserves are obtained, it requires more money and energy to get lower quality reserves.

Continue reading →

Posted in Agriculture | Tagged , , , , , , | Comments Off on Phosphate: All hopes for food and LFP batteries rest on Morocco with up to 85% of remaining reserves

Floating Solar Farms add plastic, metal, PFAS & cut off light and oxygen to life below

Preface.  These exist mainly in Asia. Yet another mess left for future generations after the fossil party ends, meanwhile, in some cases, harming the ecosystem and  reducing phytoplankton and fish while increasing toxic cyanobacteria blooms and invasive bio-fouling mussels. Few solar panels are recycled.

Continue reading →

Posted in Photovoltaic Solar | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Floating Solar Farms add plastic, metal, PFAS & cut off light and oxygen to life below

Peak Lithium

Brine and hard rock mining

Preface. The electrification of vehicles and energy storage depend on lithium batteries. What is really dumb is that energy storage systems do not need to be light like transportation batteries. Yet over 99% of energy storage systems use lithium batteries. A 200 MWh Battery energy storage system uses as much lithium as 3,300 EVs with 60 kWh batteries.

About 60% of lithium is mined from brine (lithium carbonate) because it is the cheapest. And an ecological disaster, consuming 456 billion liters of water in 2024, about 2 million liters of water per ton.

The other 40% comes from hard rock mining of Spodumene/Pegmatites. Which is more expensive and uses more energy.

There is not enough lithium to make electrifying transportation and energy storage in the long run, even with recycling. Which is not happening much now because it is not profitable. When it is, it is due to government subsidies, which cannot be counted on to last.  An NMC battery is more profitable to recycle than an LFP due to the higher value of nickel and cobalt, and only they will be extracted. Not the lithium.

Continue reading →

Posted in Metals | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Peak Lithium

Trump eliminates birth control abroad

source: Kenrick DT (2021) The Psychology of Denying Overpopulation. MAHB

Preface.  This article points out that unmanaged population growth tends to lead to instability, poverty, and migration to Europe and the U.S. But does not address the dozens of other overshoot factors human overpopulation are causing such as pollution, biodiversity loss, deforestation, soil erosion, climate change, and so on. So dumb given Peak Everything and a carrying capacity of about 500,000 without fossil fuels for transportation, fertilizer, heat, electricity, concrete, steel and virtually every other human activity and manufactured product.

Continue reading →

Posted in Birth Control, Feminism, Overpopulation | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on Trump eliminates birth control abroad

In a world without people, how long would NYC last?

Preface.  The best book I have read on this topic of how fast the world would recover is Alan Weisman’s “World Without Us.”  But this article from Popular Science is a god summary of what to expect.  And since NYC is one of the most vulnerable to sea level rise on earth, not implausible that few will remain, and what that will do to the city is not included in what follows.

Durn S (2025) In a world without people, how fast would NYC fall apart? Here’s the timeline.
In a week, mold moves in. In a century, New York is a forest. Popular Science

Imagine the ceaseless cacophony of New York City suddenly stopped. No sirens wailed. No cars zoomed. No subways rumbled beneath sidewalks.  no one’s around to sweep the sidewalks, weed Central Park. nature would move in—and quick. Dandelions spring up in asphalt cracks. Raccoons would move into abandoned apartments.  But just how swiftly would the city disappear beneath a curtain of green? We talked to architects and urban ecologists to map out a potential timeline.

Continue reading →

Posted in Infrastructure & Collapse | Tagged , , | Comments Off on In a world without people, how long would NYC last?